Vidyalelo
Political Science · Q507

Political Institutions in India

Graduate and Post Graduate · Political Science · question 507

Q507

If the Preamble were to be dropped from the Constitution, then which of the following statements will be correct? 1. The Constitution will loose its basic character. 2. The Constitution will loose a part of its basic structure. 3. The Constitution will loose its legal enforceability. 4. The Constitution will remain unaffected. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

A.
1, 2 and 3
Answer
B.
2 and 4
C.
Only 4
D.
None of these

Answer: Option A

Solution

Answer: Option A
Solution:
If the Preamble were to be dropped from the Constitution:

1. The Constitution will lose its basic character: The Preamble outlines the philosophy and guiding principles of the Constitution. Removing it would mean the Constitution loses its ideological foundation.

2. The Constitution will lose a part of its basic structure: The Preamble is considered an integral part of the basic structure doctrine, as established by the Supreme Court of India.

3. The Constitution will lose its legal enforceability: While the Preamble itself is not legally enforceable, it plays a critical role in interpreting other provisions of the Constitution.

4. The Constitution will remain unaffected: This is incorrect because the Preamble has a significant role in shaping the essence of the Constitution.

Thus, the correct answer is 1, 2, and 3.